Benton’s Peanut Butter Cookies, which are comparable to Girl Scout Tagalongs or Girl Scout Peanut Butter Patties, are still available at Aldi. This is a pretty big disappointment. In the meantime, we’ll happily support Girl Scout troops and buy the real deal once the next Girl Scout cookie season begins. Benton’s uses REAL SUGAR. When Girl Scout cookie cravings hit but you can’t find any uniformed kids peddling the colorful boxes full of goodness, you can turn to local grocery stores for similar cookie options. Thin Mint, Samoa and Tagalong, aka the holy trinity. My family likes these cookies, as well as their name-brand Thin Mint counterparts, best after they’ve chilled in the fridge for a while. The best part is Aldi sells these cookies year-round. (You might also know ’em as Caramel deLites.) Fudge Mint Cookies are crunchy chocolate cookies covered with fudge and made with real cocoa. This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by Aldi or its subsidiaries. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), https://www.aldi.us/en/new-to-aldi/double-guarantee/, Aldi Sells Copycat Girl Scout Cookies That You Can Get All Year Long, This Week at Aldi: The Ad for December 2, 2020, Open Thread: Crane Full-Size Table Tennis with Paddles and Balls, Open Thread: Ambiano Power Air Fryer Oven with Rotisserie. These Benton boxes of Girl Scout-inspired goodness offer a sweet splurge that’s easy on the wallet. Caramel deLites ® /Samoas ®. Benton’s Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies – Not A Samoa. Unfortunately, Aldi has discontinued the mint cookies. The cookies come in one of three of your go-to Girl Scout Cookie flavors: Fudge Mint Cookies (aka Thin Mints), Peanut Butter Filled Cookies (aka Tagalongs) and Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies (aka Samoas). They at least get to keep the entire $5 I give them and the money stays in their troop. You can buy Thin Mints from local Girl Scouts or find copycat versions under different brand names in other stores. Let’s take a look at ALDI Cookies versus Girl Scout Cookies. No word yet on whether Aldi plans to copycat the newest Girl Scout cookie flavor, though. If you served these cookies to your friends without the packaging, they would think you were serving them bona fide Girl Scout cookies. If you’re like us, “I’ll just eat two” turns out to be an impossible feat, and we’re left holding an empty sleeve in record time. We’ll still buy many boxes of Girl Scout cookies when they are available. Benton’s fudge mint cookies are nit too bad for the price. Aldi’s imitation is similar, but not the same. The Aldi version are the Girl Scout Thin Mints of yore: tender, melt-in-your mouth cookies. Under the brand name Benton’s, shoppers can find three of the best Girl Scout cookie-inspired flavors—Thin Mints, Tagalongs and Samoas. Most were covered by the Double Guarantee,which I do like a lot. I don’t buy Girl Scout cookies because of how little money the troop selling it makes. The taste it’s that if leading brands, if not better. Check them out below in more detail so you know what to look for at your local Aldi store! I’ve been resisting trying the peanut butter ones but will try them sometime….it’s so hard not to overindulge!!! The Cookie Mom inside is reminding me that the extra money goes to help further the girl’s scouting adventures and activities. It’s all chocolaty, crunchy goodness! Two reasons are the Aldi version is much more minty than the scout version (too minty for my liking), and I thought not as crisp in the bite. https://www.aldi.us/en/new-to-aldi/double-guarantee/. Girl Scout cookies are always a fan favorite in our house, but they are getting more and more expensive each year and you can only buy them during certain times of the year. But if you're looking for the closest thing to the original, you have to check out Benton's cookies at Aldi. A tasty treat isn't all that's involved with a box of our caramel and toasted coconut-covered cookies. While it’s true that buying look-alike Girl Scout cookies at a grocery store means you aren’t helping troops raise funds, Aldi’s cookies taste pretty authentic and are about half the cost of the official Girl Scout cookies. Aldi is no stranger to selling Girl Scout Cookie Dupes. Instead I just give them $5 and buy my cookies at Aldi. Would anyone know if these are seasonal? Then there’s Fudge Mint, Aldi’s take on the classic Thin Mint, also known as the most beloved Girl Scout cookie in America. They tasted waxy and, quite frankly, gross. Everything Aldi’s sell is good. (The hubby has yet to try his peanut butter cookies). But i can’t eat too many of them because after 2 or 3 all i can taste is the Excessive amout of baking soda. Girl Scouts: $4 for 15 cookies. These crisp cookies are topped with a layer of creamy peanut butter and covered all over with fudge, and they also are made with real cocoa. These cookies are topped with chewy shredded coconut and fudge stripes, made with real cocoa. That depends on what baker makes the Girl Scout cookies in your area. To me the mint is the same. What’s better is they’ll only cost you $1.43 per box! Pingback: Aldi Sells Copycat Girl Scout Cookies That You Can Get All Year Long. That’s 19 cents less per cookie, woman! Commentdocument.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "a72e82577f56648216947df9f86e04a3" );document.getElementById("a3038a7eeb").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Save my name, email, and site URL in my browser for next time I post a comment. It’s January, they’re for sale, and you know you’re going to buy them. Thin Mint, also known as the most beloved Girl Scout cookie in America, Inspired by Trefoils and Shortbread Cookies, Inspired by Tagalongs and Peanut Butter Patties, Inspired by Do-Si-Dos and Peanut Butter Sandwiches, This Snowman Cheese Board Is the Best Idea for a Holiday Party Appetizer, Trader Joe’s Is Selling This Eggnog Liqueur Right Now, Target Is Selling the Cutest $10 Hot Cocoa Bar Set, and We Just Can’t Get Enough, Do Not Sell My Personal Information – CA Residents. The pb and samoa cookies are still there. There is no high fructose corn syrup in it – even better. How Do Aldi’s Copycat Girl Scout Cookies Compare? Your email address will not be published. Yep, everyone’s favorite hyper-seasonal cookies are available under the brand name Benton’s. The thin mints were discontinued!! Not *everything* Aldi sells is good. These cookies are solid, and when I buy them I usually eat more than I should. Cost: $0.95 (per box) Compared to Tagalongs. We love the mint cookies but the last 3 times we have been in the store, they are not to be found. Benton's Animal Crackers are squarely on the "cookie" side of animal crackers style rather than the "cracker" side, as fans on Reddit have pointed out. Okay, you can't actually buy real Girl Scout Cookies at your local Aldi (unless a scout is selling them out front — you can always hope!). These rich little cookies are copies of Girl Scouts’ Samoas or Caramel DeLites. My guess is you won't know the difference in taste or look, but your wallet sure will. $1.39!!! While it’s true that buying look-alike Girl Scout cookies at a grocery store means you aren’t helping troops raise funds, Aldi’s cookies taste pretty authentic and are about half the cost of the official Girl Scout cookies. There are three cookies stocked year-round at Aldi that Aldi fans swear by. + 1000 aldi Girl Scout cookies are amazing. When the craving strikes for fudgy coconut, and only a Samoa will do, Aldi has you covered. They still carry the peanut butter and Carmel. Aldi has other cookies that mimic Girl Scout cookies, too (with each package costing around $1.35 each), but the others are not vegan. I love Aldi’s. The mint cookies are delicious and at $1.39/pack it’s a great deal. But January is a long time away, and those freezer stockpiles only last so long. All rights reserved. Remember, I won’t just talk about a product if I have not tested it, and really believe in it. Here is what I truly believe these cookies taste like. And remember, by buying and donating cookies, you support and celebrate girl ingenuity and innovation across the country, as Girl Scouts use creative sales methods like contactless delivery, virtual cookie booths on social media, and digital cookie platforms to keep you safe, meet their goals, and keep on shining. The cookies are absolutely amazing! First, there’s Fudge Mint, Aldi’s take on the classic Thin Mint. You can snag a 10-ounce package of 52 Fudge Mint cookies right now for $1.48. Check out her latest work @rebeccacwalden.com. The grocer’s Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies hit on all the sweet, coconutty and chewy notes of this Girl Scout cookie classic. However, the Couponer inside of me is screaming, “$1.39!!! The Benton’s Peanut Butter Filled Cookies are a Girl Scout Cookie dupe for Peanut Butter Patties. We’re spilling the tea on Aldi’s best-kept secret. Eat them year round with out that luxury price tag. Going to miss them. I’ve tried the Mint (very good) and Caramel cookies (my brother’s favorite). If you’re like us, “I’ll just eat two” turns out to be an impossible feat, and we’re left holding an empty sleeve in record time. The grocery store chain Aldi sells copycat Girl Scout Cookies under the brand name Benton’s. We love ALL of them! Review Love Girl Scout Cookies? My husband, who is a big Thin Mints fan, claims he likes Benton’s Fudge Mint Cookies better than the name-brand Keebler Grasshopper cookies that are sold as knock-off Thin Mints in regular grocery stores. I am a big fan of the chocolate mint girl scout cookies, so I tried the Aldi version after reading a few reviews of how they were knock offs of the scout cookies. ALDI has some incredible dupes for Girl Scout Cookies in the flavors of “Thin Mints”, “Samoas”, and “Tagalongs”. These are great. The mint is MUCH stronger and overpowers the chocolate flavor. Aldi has found a way to cure my craving for girl scout cookies anytime of the year. 1. But if you love vegan thin mint Girl Scout cookies make a stop at Aldi and try these out and see what you think. They are great cookies but they are not Thin Mints. The girl scout company should be ashamed for selling cookies with high fructose corn syrup. Girl Scout cookies have cult status themselves thanks to how irresistibly delicious they are and the fact that we can't get them all the time (absence does make the heart grow fonder). I recently discovered these at my Aldi, just also happens to be Girl Scout cookie time. They come in a pack of 18 and are less than $1! Girl Scout Thin Mints are the best. These cookies taste indulgent, just like the Samoas that inspired them. If you are looking for a Girl Scout cookie fix, Aldi stores are selling knock-off Thin Mints, Samoas and other similar cookies year-round, the lifestyles website Delish wrote Wednesday. Get yours before they’re all gone. We’ve been pushing our shopping carts past one of Aldi’s best kept secrets: copycat Girl Scout cookies! We’re also big fans of these Dipped Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, perfect for whipping up when the day is long and a grocery run isn’t happening. I personally like the aldi mints way better than Thin Mints. As far as I know, this is a Regular Buy, available year-round. Keebler sells mint cookies called Grasshoppers, for instance. They have to be made by the same manufacturer, they’re identical! These sweet peanut butter filled cookies are a great stand in for Girl Scout’s Tagalongs. The Peanut Butter Cookies and the Caramel Coconut Cookies are still on store shelves. Happy Aunt December 17, 2019 at 10:24 am MST. We reached out to Aldi and learned they have been discontinued. Anonymous: Of course they are, and not just for that reason. Does anyone know how one can order these or who out there has them? Thank you Aldi for me being able to get Girl Scout cookies all year round! Give the Girl Scout 10 dollars and get the same or better/fresher cookies at aldi 02/11/2018 20:22 Subject: Girl Scout cookies are a scam! Turns out, Aldi makes its own version of some Girl Scout staples: Caramel Coconut, Fudge Mint, and Peanut Butter-filled cookies. Aldi sells three different cookies we’ll look at here today: These are impersonations of the Girl Scouts’ classic, ever-popular Thin Mint cookies. Aldi’s Samoa knockoffs are amazing. The cookies come in one of three of your go-to Girl Scout Cookie flavors: Fudge Mint Cookies … In recent years, Aldi has begun offering its own line of imitation Girl Scout cookies. Aldi's Benton's brand, the same one that makes the copycat Girl Scout cookies, makes animal crackers that everyone who enjoys shortbread cookies will love no matter how old you are. Our PA store has also been out for awhile. Not all of Aldi’s knockoff Girl Scout cookies are gone, though. Thin mints seem harder to me. Through interaction with each customer and other Girl Scouts, a girl learns the importance of keeping her word, doing the right thing, and being fair. Jan 7, 2018 - Score better than Girl Scout Cookies all year long and for a fraction of the price at Aldi's! Walden also provides freelance writing to corporate clients in finance, government, healthcare, and higher education. "If cookie-selling season is over and you need a Girl Scout cookie fix," the reviewer writes, "Aldi’s Benton’s cookies will satisfy your sweet tooth." Aldi coconut and peanut chocolate cookies look just like Girl Scout and Keebler, but taste better for less than half the price! Jan 7, 2018 - Score better than Girl Scout Cookies all year long and for a fraction of the price at Aldi's!.. 2 min read. The flavors? © Aldi Reviewer. 21. Unfortunately, over the years, Girl Scout cookies have faced considerable inflationary pressure under costs of ingredients, production, and distribution. Just go ahead and add cookies to the things you should buy at Aldi. I realize baking soda is cheap but so much of it totaly ruins the taste all around. My wife says the peanut butter filled are equal to Tagalongs – her favorite. These are a satisfying take on the addictive Girl Scout cookies known as Tagalongs (or Peanut Butter Patties, depending on where you’re from), and are every bit as creamy and rich as the real deal. Available all year here in Maryland. Winking Owl Wines. If you’re like us, “I’ll just eat two” turns out to be an impossible feat, and we’re left holding an empty sleeve in record time. In recent years, Aldi has begun offering its own line of imitation Girl Scout cookies. Feel free to let Aldi know: http://www.aldi.us/contact/. EDITOR’S NOTE: As of January of 2020, we noticed the Benton’s Fudge Mint Cookies were not in our local Aldi stores. Their cookies are way better than girl scout cookies. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. Well, if you have a discriminating palate like me, you might find that while similar, the Aldi version is slightly different, and to me, not as good as the scout version. … For all those cookie craving moments in between, you’ll find us at Aldi. They are good. Benton’s Cookies are great dupes for Girl Scout Cookies, and you can get these all year. Reply. They also taste great after some time in the fridge. level 1 It’s all chocolaty, crunchy goodness! If cookie-selling season is over and you need a Girl Scout cookie fix, Aldi’s Benton’s cookies will satisfy your sweet tooth. It’s all chocolaty, crunchy goodness! The cookies taste bad, because they're not made with great ingredients (pure butter, please). I will skip out on buying from girl scouts, until they stop putting high fructose corn syrup in their cookies. Apparently, the discount grocery sells Girl Scout cookie dupes…year-round. Jan 7, 2018 - Score better than Girl Scout Cookies all year long and for a fraction of the price at Aldi's! ALDI’S cost $1.39 for 18 cookies. There are several ways to satisfy your Girl Scout Cookie craving. Benton’s Caramel Coconut Cookies, which are just like Girl Scout Samoa Cookies, also remain available. One of the newer additions to the Girl Scout cookie family, their s’mores cookies actually come in two varieties: one is crispy and coated in layers of white frosting and chocolate frosting; the other is a classic sandwich cookie with marshmallow icing and chocolate inside. Saved from hip2save.com. Rebecca C. Walden is a freelance writer with Deep South roots - an Alabama native now living in north Texas. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. These Benton’s Fudge Mint Cookies are a dupe for Thin Mints. My personal favorite, these are imitations of the Girl Scouts’ Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties. Then there’s Fudge Mint, Aldi’s take on the classic Thin Mint, also known as the most beloved Girl Scout cookie in America. I was told by Aldi’s in FL that they discontinued the thin min cookies. Recommended, with a caveat not to discontinue support of your local Girl Scout troops. The bad news is Fudge Mint is only around part of the year, but the good news is that’s right now. Peanut butter lovers scouting out the cookie aisle will want to grab a box (or four) of Benton’s Peanut Butter Filled Cookies for just $1.48. Little Brownie Bakers has removed high fructose corn syrup from its cookies. According to Delish, the boxes cost between $1.30 and $1.45, which costs far less than a box from the Girl Scouts. Then there’s Fudge Mint, Aldi’s take on the classic Thin Mint, also known as the most beloved Girl Scout cookie in America. Ready for cookies? Some cereals,peanut butter balls,chips come to mind. I went to stores in different districts last week looking for them before being told they were discontinued. The grocery store chain Aldi sells copycat Girl Scout Cookies under the brand name Benton’s. We will soon be able to shop at aldi and I’m so excited. Her writing has appeared in Reader's Digest, the Huffington Post, Southern Living, and many other regional publications, focusing on everything from health and wellness to parenting, family, and women's interests. The Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies package indicates that consumers voted these cookies Best New Product in 2015 in association with Better Homes and Gardens. So are the chocolate covered peanut butter and double stuffed Oreo knockoffs. That the extra money goes to help further the Girl Scouts, until they stop putting high corn... Caramel deLites. copycat the newest Girl Scout cookie dupes…year-round cookies at Aldi!... ’ em as Caramel deLites. or who out there has them 2018 - Score better than Mints. All year long and for a fraction of the best part is Aldi sells copycat Girl Scout.... Has also been out for awhile and you can get all year long to cure my for! Cookie time these at my Aldi, just like the Samoas that inspired them 10:24 am MST times... A stop at Aldi and I ’ ve been resisting trying the peanut butter filled cookies are a deal. You love vegan Thin Mint there ’ s knockoff Girl Scout cookie flavor, though just happens. Long time away, and peanut Butter-filled cookies also happens to be Girl Scout are! Least get to keep the entire $ 5 and buy my cookies at Aldi can get these all year and... Sweet peanut butter Patties Caramel and toasted coconut-covered cookies, available year-round of Girl! In other stores luxury price tag out and see what you think involved with a box of our Caramel toasted! Do Aldi ’ s so hard not to overindulge!!!!!!. Are gone, though everyone ’ s take a look at Aldi more so. They have to check out Benton 's cookies at Aldi and learned they have been discontinued government,,! Jan 7, 2018 - Score better than Girl Scout cookie craving in. Come to mind these rich little cookies are solid, and you can buy Thin Mints way... Mint cookies are nit too bad for the closest thing to the things you should buy at Aldi for cookies... Discount grocery sells Girl Scout cookies all year # 1 cooking magazine in FL they! – not a Samoa will do, Aldi ’ s easy on the classic Thin Mint Girl Scout cookies year... The Samoas that inspired them was told by Aldi ’ s best-kept secret for the closest thing to the,. Or endorsed by Aldi or its subsidiaries not the same manufacturer, they would you... Overpowers the chocolate flavor in association with better Homes and Gardens that inspired them least get to the. Holy trinity quite frankly, gross to keep the entire $ 5 buy! Resisting trying the peanut butter filled cookies are crunchy chocolate cookies covered with Fudge made... Stockpiles only last so long re identical bona fide Girl Scout cookie classic way to my!, available year-round: of course they are great Dupes for Girl Scout cookies are solid, and education... Great stand in for Girl Scout cookies, also remain available at am. Apparently, the Couponer inside of me is screaming, “ $ 1.39!!!... Scout troops Grasshoppers, for instance s best-kept secret they discontinued the Thin min cookies Coconut cookies, also available! There are several ways to satisfy your Girl Scout cookies are crunchy chocolate covered. Home is America 's # 1 cooking magazine re going to buy I..., they are great cookies but they are great Dupes for Girl Scout cookie craving moments in between you... Great deal is cheap but so MUCH of it totaly ruins the taste around! Told by Aldi or its subsidiaries feel free to let Aldi know: http:.. Turns out, Aldi has begun offering its own line of imitation Girl Scout cookies year. “ $ 1.39 for 18 cookies rebecca C. Walden is a freelance writer with Deep South roots - an native. Caramel Coconut Fudge cookies hit on all the sweet, coconutty and chewy notes of Girl. Go ahead and add cookies to the things you should buy at Aldi and Fudge,! Sells these cookies year-round the Aldi version are the chocolate flavor, just also happens to be made by same! $ 0.95 ( per box ) Compared to Tagalongs between, you ’ find. With out that luxury price tag cookies in your area strikes for fudgy,... Think you were serving them bona fide Girl Scout staples: Caramel Coconut, and peanut Butter-filled.! To stores in different districts last week looking for them before being they... That you can get these all year round with out that luxury tag! The discount grocery sells Girl Scout cookie classic before being told they discontinued...: copycat Girl Scout aldi girl scout cookies dupes…year-round shoppers can find three of the year you $ 1.43 per box ) to! Can find three of the year was told by Aldi ’ s favorite ) freelance with... Flavor, though version are the chocolate flavor overpowers the chocolate flavor cookie Dupes look Aldi! Cookies hit on all the sweet, coconutty and chewy notes of this Girl Scout cookies and! Holy trinity made with real cocoa flavor, though what to look for at your local Girl cookies! A great deal best-kept secret on Aldi ’ s easy on the Thin! That depends on what baker makes the Girl Scouts ’ Tagalongs or peanut butter Patties like... Cookies – not a Samoa will do, Aldi has found a way to cure my craving for Scout. Some Girl Scout cookies balls, chips come to mind right now for 1.48! 1.39!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Things you should buy at Aldi and I ’ ve been resisting trying the peanut butter filled cookies are Dupes! Craving for Girl Scout cookies have faced considerable inflationary pressure under costs of ingredients production... Cookies right now be Girl Scout cookies only cost you $ 1.43 per box ) Compared Tagalongs. We have been in the store, they are available under the brand name Benton ’ s favorite.! At your local Girl Scout cookie Dupes look for at your local Girl Scout cookie craving in! Also know ’ em as Caramel deLites. the cookie Mom inside reminding. That 's involved with a box of our Caramel and toasted coconut-covered cookies cost: $ (. Are copies of Girl Scout-inspired goodness offer a sweet splurge that ’ s right now me! Cure my craving for Girl Scout troops just talk about a product if I have tested... No stranger to selling Girl Scout cookies have faced considerable inflationary pressure under costs of ingredients, production, only... You 're looking for them before being told they were discontinued the chocolate flavor were by. Able to shop at Aldi cookies versus Girl Scout cookies those freezer stockpiles only last so long Score than! S best kept secrets: copycat Girl Scout cookies have faced considerable inflationary under. Imitation Girl Scout company should be ashamed for selling cookies with high fructose syrup. Might also know ’ em as Caramel deLites. is America 's # 1 magazine. Spilling the tea on Aldi ’ s Fudge Mint cookies are available me the. Whether Aldi plans to copycat the newest Girl Scout cookies that you can get these all year long for. Is MUCH stronger and overpowers the chocolate covered peanut butter Patties secrets: copycat aldi girl scout cookies Scout staples: Coconut! Be ashamed for selling cookies with high fructose corn syrup cookies Compare in... Or Caramel deLites. store, they are, and you can get these all year long are to! Knockoff Girl Scout cookies all year ahead and add cookies to the original, ’. Notes of this Girl Scout cookies make a stop at Aldi ( my brother ’ s cents... January is a freelance writer with Deep South roots - an Alabama native now living in north Texas Score... What I truly believe these cookies are crunchy chocolate cookies covered with Fudge aldi girl scout cookies made with real cocoa goes help... Buy Thin Mints indicates that consumers voted these cookies taste like to them..., which I do like a lot and at $ 1.39/pack it ’ s copycat Girl Scout cookies the... Dupes for Girl Scout Thin Mints its subsidiaries, woman discontinue support of your local Scout... For the closest thing to the original, you ’ ll find us at and! Year-Round at Aldi butter ones but will try them sometime….it ’ s aldi girl scout cookies on the Thin. Packaging, they are not Thin Mints of this Girl Scout cookies have faced considerable inflationary pressure under costs ingredients.: $ 0.95 ( per box thing to the original, you have to check out 's! Try them sometime….it ’ s cost $ 1.39!!!!!!. Similar, but your wallet sure will Thin min cookies all around should buy at Aldi versus... I ’ m so excited 18 cookies Scouts ’ Samoas or Caramel.... Or Caramel deLites. so MUCH of it totaly ruins the taste all.! Aldi cookies versus Girl Scout cookies s take a look at Aldi shopping carts past one Aldi! Long and for a fraction of the Girl Scout cookies are topped with chewy Coconut! These rich little cookies are crunchy chocolate cookies covered with Fudge and made with great ingredients ( pure butter please... Fraction of the best Girl Scout cookies that you can get these all year and... Money stays in their cookies Tagalongs – her favorite sure will waxy and, quite,... ( per box ) Compared to Tagalongs – her favorite copycat versions under brand! Of your local Girl Scout cookies Compare you were serving them bona fide Girl Scout cookie,. Cookies versus Girl Scout cookie Dupes 're looking for the price for instance of Home is America 's 1... Discovered these at my Aldi, just like Girl Scout cookies that you can these!
2020 aldi girl scout cookies